Posted on

Recipe For Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapenos

Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapenos: An Easy, Cheap and Tasty Appetizer

Don’t you just love when you find things you can easily cook at home, especially when they take zero cooking skills?

Sure, you’re probably thinking that there are loads of things you can cook that don’t take much skill to make…it’s just that most of those things either don’t have that satisfying taste you crave, or the ones that do taste good are so loaded with salt, preservatives and other scary ingredients that you figure you might as well just grab some takeout instead and save the hassle of cooking.

One beautiful thing about the combination of Jalapeno and Peanut Butter is that you can buy large quantities and still typically only spend a few dollars.

Second, anything with Peanut Butter is all the right types of indulgent in our book!

Take this as your next appetizer to any potluck and you’ll probably have everybody asking how you thought of it.

If you’ve never had the combination of Peanut Butter and Jalapeno before, you’re probably thinking that this dish SOUNDS strange. Not to fear, because we almost can guarantee your taste buds will thank you when you give this simple appetizer a try.

This decadent combination of spicy and savory, salty and sweet, makes for an unforgettable combination that you’ll want to make again and again. But don’t just take our word for it, check out below how easy this really is to make and you can make it for yourself today!

It’s hard to pick a best part, but remember that you will only have a few minutes of total prep time. The longest part of this process is just letting these babies cook to perfection before you dig in!

Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapenos:


Fresh, whole Jalapenos (cook as many as you want because the recipe is the same no matter the number you choose to cook, from 3 to 30, etc.)

Peanut Butter (use your favorite kind; crunchy obviously provides a little more texture, but creamy is what we traditionally use)

¼ Cup Water (or just enough to create some steam)


Any sharp knife will do, but a Paring Knife is ideal

Glass Baking Dish


Wash your fresh Jalapenos

Slice a slit length-wise down the entire Jalapeno; repeat this for each pepper.

Scoop out all seeds with a spoon, discard the seeds, and rinse the pepper once more (unless you want to keep the heat)

Scoop approximately 1 Tablespoon of Peanut Butter (or enough to fill generously) into EACH Jalapeno

Fill baking dish with all Jalapenos, then

Pour the water in the dish

Bake @ 400 Degrees for 20-30 minutes or until the Jalapenos look cooked to your liking. (You want them to change from their natural shade of dark green to a lighter green similar to the shade in the image above).

Then, for the BEST PART!

Enjoy these amazing little treats and savor your first fantasy unlocked with Fantaskey. We hope you enjoy these delicious little devils as much as we do. Leave a comment below to let us know what you think.

For an easy, tasty, affordable appetizer that you can prepare in just a few minutes, we want to see if you get a kick (pun intended) out of these Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapenos!

2 thoughts on “Recipe For Peanut Butter Stuffed Jalapenos

  1. This was incredible, and incredibly easy! Plus, I only spent a few bucks making a huge pan full.

    Thank you!

    Now I have a new go-to appetizer for sure!

  2. They look amazing! I am entertaining this weekend and am going to try them, will let you know. 🙂

Leave a Reply